Top 10 Best Rated Crib Mattresses 2019


We have taken out time to look at the best crib mattresses for 2019. This list is a product of thorough scrutiny by top reviewers globally and has been compiled to enable you make the right buying decision.

Also, you should know that we did not arrange these according to any particular order.

1. Newton Wovenaire

Made in the US, the Newton Wovenaire crib mattress is an award-winning mattress and does not have two sides.  It is halfway between soft and hard and thus, you may never have any reason to flip it over.

Here are some of its features:

  • It is Greenguard GOLD Certified
  • Made of 90 percent air polymer
  • Zippered cover
  • Price: $300


  • Very firm
  • Lightweight
  • Durable
  • Breathable cover and thus reduction in risk of suffocation
  • Machine washable


  • It is a bit more pricey
  • Also, you have to shell out a good amount of money to buy the replacement cover

2. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

With awesome squared corner, this cheap crib mattress is arguably one of the best you can get your hands on and will be well worth your money.  It is made in the US and

  • Is Greenguard GOLD certified
  • Low VOC features
  • Squared corners
  • A long excluded chemical list
  • Waterproof and seamless cover
  • Dual firmness
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Antimicrobial coating
  • Price: $199


  • Softcover
  • The sheets are easy to change
  • Washing is not always frequent as the cover is stain resistant
  • Firm
  • Lightweight


  • The smell is a bit strong
  • No guarantee that it would last long or it’s durable

3. Babyletto Pure Core

A relatively new crib mattress, the Babyletto Pure Core Non-Toxic Mattress is double-sided. It fits in well into the crib and has these features:

  • It is hypoallergenic
  • Dual-sided
  • It has a non-toxic core
  • Dust mite and allergen resistant
  • There is also a cotton cover
  • A vinyl-free waterproof liner
  • Price: $199


  • Machine washable
  • The cover zips on and off easily
  • Perfect softness for a toddler
  • A nicely structured sides
  • The core can be recycled
  • Fits in well into crib


  • Has greater chance of shrinking when washed
  • The zipper is of low

4. Emily Natural Crib Mattress

An all-natural mattress for cribs, this product has no urethane and also looks like a mattress for grown-up mattress. It has these as its features:

  • A Greenguard GOLD certification
  • All-natural
  • Real stitched seams
  • No vinyl cover
  • GOTS organic cotton quilted cover
  • Needle perforations
  • Price: $250


  • It is breathable
  • Ideal for winter and summer
  • There is no odor
  • It is also comfortable for all ages
  • Fits perfectly to the crib
  • You can flip it over every few months
  • Low chemical emission


  • You buy a separate cover for this crib mattress

5. Colgate Eco Classica III

It is a foam core and has pretty low VOC emissions. And this, added to its dual firmness and very affordable price, undoubtedly makes the Colgate Eco Classica III crib mattress one of the best out there.

These are its features below:

  • A certified organic cover
  • Dual-sided
  • Price: $47


  • High quality
  • Well-constructed
  • Soft cotton
  • Lightweight
  • Easy to change the sheets and pad
  • Fits well into the crib
  • Has a better chance of lasting long


  • Not fully organic

6. Naturepedic No Compromise

This mattress is ideal for your baby if you want a full organic one and it has a lesser chance of shrinking.

It also meets the Greenguard and GOTS certifications standards and has other features like:

  • It is an organic cotton padding and cover
  • Comes without a coil
  • Squared corners
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Water proof organic covering
  • Price: $250


  • Less likely to sag
  • It is odorless
  • Cover is easy to clean
  • Fits well into the crib
  • More likely to last long
  • A nice and firm toddler’s side


  • It is heavier when compared to other
  • It is also expensive

7. Lullaby Earth Breeze

A Greenguard Certified mattress with low VOC emissions, it is fully recyclable, and one of the most breathable mattress.  It has the following features:

  • The corners are squared
  • Has round edges
  • Non vinyl cover
  • Minimal VOC emissions
  • Dual firmness
  • Water proof cover
  • Greenguard Certified
  • Price: $170


  • It is quite easy to clean
  • Softer toddler side
  • Well-constructed
  • Could easily last long


  • The corners are not nicely squared
  • When under any weight, it sags a bit on the edges

8. Simmons Kids Beauty Rest

It has a supportive coil core and great quality and chance of lasting longer than others in the category.  These are some of the features of the Simmons Kids Beauty Rest Crib Mattress:

  • Rounded corner
  • Metal vents on the side
  • Greenguard and CertiPUR-US certification for low VOC emissions
  • Woven fabric cover
  • Price: $100


  • Cheap
  • It fits well into the crib
  • It lasts long
  • Great build and quality


  • The sheets are difficult to change
  • It is heavier than many crib mattresses
  • It has a not-so-nice odor

9. Milliard Hypoallergenic

It is part of the Milliard series of crib and toddler bed mattresses, and is CertiPUR-US® certified, this means it is eco-system friendly with low VOC emissions. It is a very cheap crib mattress and has these features:

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof sheets
  • Cover for the tops and sides
  • 90-degree edges
  • Price: $55


  • Easy to clean
  • Not harmful to your kids
  • The cover helps in stopping spills from damaging the mattress
  • It fits pretty well into the crib
  • Super compact


  • Not as comfortable as others on this list
  • It’s not reversible dual-firmness for varied support levels,
  • It’s not as thick as most others on this list

10. Graco Premium Foam

Another inexpensive mattress you can get for your baby’s crib, it comes with foam core.  It has a petroleum-based material that emits volatile organic compounds (VOCs).

These are some of its features:

  • Zipper pull
  • Washable zippered cover
  • Not Greenguard or CertiPur certified
  • Squared corners
  • Price: $60


  • Inexpensive
  • Easy to use
  • Easy to move around


  • Quite hard
  • The cover is not waterproof